Are you into project Management and planning? You may already know that these two are essential elements for all businesses. You will also find several certifications available online to become an efficient project management professional. The common question that comes to everyone’s mind is - which is better? The PMP® certification or the professional training certifications in Agile. Both methodologies are ideal for professionals in certain circumstances. Scroll down to learn how to make a better decision and understand the Agile vs PMP comparison.
Before we move forward, let us brush up on some basics, shall we?
Agile Certification
An Agile certification helps recognize your expertise in different Agile concepts. The course also signals to employers that you have taken the time to study and earn the particular credential as a professional. Agile certifications can make sure to level up your career in project management. They can also assist you in implementing Agile practices into your work environment.
Here are some general requirements of the Agile certification:
- Secondary degree in higher education (bachelor's or master's)
- Around 21 hours of direct Agile practice
- 8 to 12 months of general project experience
PMP® Certification
The PMP® certification course is an industry-recognized, acclaimed course for all project managers. It tests a particular candidate's ability to manage the people, business priorities, and processes of a specific project.
PMP® certification alone proves project leadership experience and expertise in any way of working across industries and companies. Currently, there are around 1.037 million project managers in the world who are PMP-certified professionals. This makes it a reliable course for those who want to excel in project management tasks and activities.
This particular certification has the following requirements:
- An associate or a high school diploma degree
- A four-year degree
- 36 to 60 months of experience in leading different projects
- Around 35 hours of project management education
Also, check:What is PMP® Certification? Benefits of the PMP® certification
Agile Vs. PMP Comparison
You may find several similarities between Agile and PMP because of their alignment towards project management across organizations. However, there are significant differences between the duo as shown in the comparison table below.
Criteria | Agile | PMP (Project Management Professional) |
Project Lifecycle | Iterative and Incremental | Sequential (Waterfall) |
Project Flexibility | Highly Flexible | Less Flexible, More Structured |
Change Management | Embraces Changes Throughout | Changes Follow Strict Change Control Procedures |
Project Scope | Can Be Adjusted Mid-Project | Fixed at the Beginning, Changes Controlled through SOPs |
Documentation | Emphasizes Working Solutions | Comprehensive Documentation (Plans, Reports, etc.) |
Communication | Face-to-Face Communication Emphasized | Formal Documentation and Reporting, Formalized Communication |
Roles and Responsibilities | Collaborative Teams with Shared Roles | Clearly Defined Roles and Responsibilities |
Risk Management | Ongoing Risk Assessment | Detailed Risk Management Plan |
Client Involvement | Regular and Continuous Engagement | Involvement at Key Stages and Formal Reviews |
Certification | Agile Certifications (CSM, PMI-ACP) | PMP® Certification by PMI |
Project Control | Team-Based Decision-Making | Centralized Decision-Making, Project Manager Holds Authority |
Customer Satisfaction | Prioritizes Customer Satisfaction | Customer Satisfaction Addressed through Defined Processes |
Resource Allocation | Adaptive Resource Allocation | Resource Allocation as Per Project Plan and Resource Constraints |
Performance Metrics | Working Product as Primary Metric | Various Metrics, Including Earned Value Management (EVM) |
Quality Assurance | Integrated Throughout the Process | Quality Management Plan and Quality Control Processes |
Scale of Projects | Well-Suited for Small to Medium Projects | Suitable for Projects of Varying Sizes, Including Large Projects |
Decision-Making Authority | Shared Among Team Members | Project Manager Holds Decision-Making Authority |
Agile Vs. PMP: Project Management Approach
This is the first parameter to distinguish between Agile and PMP. Agile is a flexible, iterative, and adaptive approach to project management. PMP, on the other hand, is a more structured and plan-driven approach to project management.
Agile also focuses on delivering small working software chunks called sprints. It then encourages regular communication and collaboration between different team members. Whereas PMP involves detailed planning and scheduling of the project's execution. It further emphasizes the importance of several project management processes.
Agile Vs. PMP: Overall Project Scope
The project's scope is more flexible and can further change throughout the project's lifecycle in Agile. The project's scope is defined at the beginning of the project in PMP. Moreover, it is supposed to stay the same.
Agile projects are more suitable for uncertain projects with a rapidly changing scope. Meanwhile, PMP is for projects that have a well-defined scope.
Agile vs PMP: Role of Project Manager
The role of the project manager in Agile is more of a facilitator. This particular professional helps the team to work together effectively. The project manager is a traditional manager in PMP who is responsible for planning and controlling the specific project.
Agile vs PMP: Documentation
Documentation is the fourth parameter for distinction. The documentation in Agile is minimal and focuses only on the essentials. However, the PMP documentation is more extensive. It often includes detailed project plans, progress reports, and schedules.
Agile vs PMP: Testing
Testing is permanently integrated into the development process in Agile. This process happens parallelly with development. Testing in PMP is done after the development phase, considered a separate phase of the specific project.
Agile vs PMP: Feedback
The feedback is continuous in Agile, and the team regularly receives feedback from the customer. However, the input is less frequent in PMP. It usually occurs at the end of each phase of the particular project.
Agile vs PMP: Change Management
Change management is flexible in Agile, which involves incorporating changes into the project at any time. On the other hand, change management in PMP is more rigid, and changes happen in the project after the change control board approves everything.
Is Agile and PMP Similar?
Despite their differences, Agile and PMP methodologies have a common goal- delivering a project on time and within budget. Both methods also emphasize the importance of collaboration and communication between team members.
Apart from that, the duo is based on continuous improvement. Agile and PMP also incorporate common project management tools. These include backlogs, Gantt charts, and burndown charts that help manage any specific project's progress.
Agile Vs. PMP: Which is Better?
Still confused about the Agile Vs. PMP distinction. Then, let us help you choose which methodology is better for your requirements.
The choice between Agile and PMP methodologies depends on the nature of the particular project and the associated organization's culture. You can choose Agile if your project requires an adaptive and flexible approach. This will help you focus on rapid delivery and immediate customer feedback. The Scrum framework may be the best choice in such cases.
You can also choose the PMI-ACP Certification that focuses on Agile methodologies and principles if you wish to expand your knowledge in Agile. This will help you learn Agile practices for different projects without going through the complete Agile certification program.
Agile Vs. PMP: Pros and Cons
We have curated another table below that further focuses on the characteristics of Agile Vs. PMP by showcasing their pros and cons. This will help you understand which among the two methodologies is better for specific requirements.
Characteristics | Agile | PMP (Project Management Professional) |
Software Deployment | Incremental and Continuous Deployment | Phased Deployment with Milestones |
Resource Usage | Efficient Use of Resources, Agile Teams Collaborate Effectively | Resource Allocation Defined at Project Initiation |
Changes in Plan Adaptation | Embraces Changes Throughout the Project Lifecycle | Changes Follow Strict Change Control Procedures |
Testing and Debugging | Continuous Testing and Debugging Throughout Development | Formal Testing Phases Followed by Debugging |
Support Community | Strong Agile Community, Collaboration and Shared Learning | Comprehensive PM Community, Structured Knowledge Sharing |
Feedback Timing | Regular and Continuous Feedback Throughout Development | Feedback at Key Milestones and End of Project |
Cost of Development and Training | Potential for Cost Savings with Agile Methods | Higher Upfront Costs for Formal Training and Planning |
Project Documentation | Light Documentation, Focus on Working Software | Comprehensive Documentation, Detailed Plans, and Reports |
Progress Measure | Working Software as Primary Measure of Progress | Progress Measured Against Project Plan and Milestones |
Client Interaction | Continuous Collaboration with Clients, Regular Demos | Limited Client Involvement Until Key Stages |
Developer Reassignment | Flexibility for Developers to Work Across Different Tasks | Roles Defined at the Start, Changes May Involve Formal Processes |
Project Duration | Shorter Iterative Cycles, Quick Delivery of Value | Comprehensive Planning May Lead to Longer Project Durations |
Project Scope | Scope Can Evolve Throughout the Project Lifecycle | Changes Follow Strict Change Control Procedures |
Estimation of Project Costs | Agile Provides Flexibility in Budgeting | Detailed Estimation and Budgeting at Project Initiation |
Product Development | Incremental and Iterative Product Development Approach | Phased and Structured Product Development |
Project Cycle | Iterative Cycles with Continuous Improvement | Phases: Initiation, Planning, Execution, Monitoring, Closure |
In Conclusion
Agile and PMP are among the most widely used project management methodologies. Yet, each has its own strengths and weaknesses when it comes to assisting project management professionals. The choice between Agile and PMP depends on the nature of the specific project, including the particular organization's culture. You must make sure to evaluate the specific needs of the project before choosing between Agile and PMP methodologies.
The same criteria apply to those baffled about choosing between Agile and PMP® certifications. Understand what you want to learn from the specific methodology, including your organizational requirements, before choosing either certification from Simpliaxis. Your goal is to ensure the project’s success by using either methodology.
Agile and PMP training from Simpliaxis can help you get the required skills.
FAQs
- Which certification is better: Agile or PMP?
You can never rate between Agile and PMP because both are two different approaches to project management. The PMP method works well for small and large organizations that choose planned methods. Yet, Agile scores well across IT industries that choose a rather rapid and conceptual approach.
- Is PMP the same as Agile project management?
The PMP syllabus is based on waterfall methods, as described in the PMBoK Guide. Whereas all the Agile certifications are based on Agile principles and Scrum methodologies.
- Is PMP still relevant with Agile?
PMP has always evolved with the needs of employers and job seekers over the years. The same goes for Agile framework and principles. It proves that both methodologies are still relevant to the project management industry.
Curious? Explore PMP® Certification: Frequently Asked Questions and Answers
+1-361-998-9988
Join the Discussion